Pip: Welcome back to Pollywog’s Place Blog, where December is apparently a full-time job with a liturgical calendar and a side of Santa Pancakes.
Mara: Susie at Pollywog’s Place Blog has been mapping out the whole season — from the feast of St. Nicholas on December sixth through the full sweep of Advent, with menus, traditions, and the theology behind all of it. Let’s start with St. Nicholas Day itself.
St. Nicholas Day: History, Feast, and Family Tradition
Pip: St. Nicholas Day lands on December sixth, and the question the posts are really asking is how you celebrate a saint in a way that actually means something — not just as a warm-up act for Christmas.
Mara: The 2025 recap puts it plainly. After the pancakes and the stockings and the scraggly wall tree dressed up with leftover craft supplies, the evening lands here: “It was a lovely evening, and just a fun tradition that helps keep the focus on JESUS while explaining the idea behind Santa Claus.”
Pip: So the feast is doing double duty — honoring a real historical figure and giving kids a framework for where Santa actually came from, rather than just letting the mythology float untethered.
Mara: The resource post for St. Nicholas Day lays out exactly how to build that framework. It lists books like “Saint Nicholas: The Real Story of the Christmas Legend” and “The Baker’s Dozen: A Saint Nicholas Tale,” alongside crafts, videos, and a cookie recipe — a full lesson plan, essentially, built around a single calendar date.
Pip: Which is also, apparently, the chosen day to put up the Christmas tree — the resource post notes that directly, and says the plan is to work it into the day’s lessons.
Mara: The 2025 post shows what that looks like in practice. The kids made Santa Pancakes with fresh fruit and whipped cream for breakfast, read “Saint Nicholas: The Real Story,” put up the small tree, and then gathered for a feast that evening in his honor.
Pip: The dessert, by her own admission, did not land. She’s already planning a hot fudge sundae cake with black cherry ice cream next year — the black cherry standing in for the “hidden works” from the St. Nicholas story.
Mara: That detail is doing real work. The food isn’t just festive; it’s meant to carry the meaning of the story forward into the meal itself.
Pip: From one feast to an entire season of them — Advent turns out to have its own table.
Advent Meals and the Rhythm of the Season
Pip: If St. Nicholas Day is the opening note, Advent is the whole score — and the question these posts are answering is what it actually looks like to eat and celebrate your way through four weeks of preparation rather than just counting down to Christmas.
Mara: The Advent menu and celebration post opens with a quote from “Fast and Feast” by Bridget Ann Henisch: “Advent is a period of preparation for Christmas, a time when man tries to turn over a new leaf and start again. One fifteenth-century sermon writer points to the parallel between the Church and the individual: just as the Church makes a fresh beginning on Advent Sunday, ‘so owe ye to begynne and renewe youre lyf.'”
Pip: A medieval sermon writer making the case for a fresh start in December. That framing shapes everything that follows — each Advent Sunday gets its own candle color, its own theme, and its own menu.
Mara: Right. Hope, Peace, Joy, Love — each Sunday has a distinct character, and the food tracks with it. The third Sunday, Gaudete, calls for a Shepherd’s Dinner spread: flatbreads, figs, hummus, olives, pomegranates, goat cheese. The December edition post pulls the same thread, mapping specific food ideas to specific dates all month long — National Cookie Day, Gingerbread House Day, a Polar Express party, the Bethlehem dinner on Christmas Eve.
Pip: The throughline in both posts is that the meal is the ritual — a way to make the season tangible for a family doing this at home.
Mara: What holds all of this together is the idea that the calendar itself is a teacher — that December sixth and the four Sundays of Advent are doing real instructional work if you let them.
Pip: Feast first, then figure out what you believe. Honestly, not the worst pedagogy. See you next time.
